Elevate Your Holiday Table: 8 Boozy Bakes Featuring New Deal Spirits

Elevate Your Holiday Table: 8 Boozy Bakes Featuring New Deal Spirits

The holidays are synonymous with two things: spirited gatherings and decadent baking. But why keep the spirits in the glass and the sweets on the plate? This season of gifting & gathering has a special way of inviting us back into the kitchen. It’s the season when butter softens on countertops all afternoon, warm spices perfume the whole house, and every gathering—no matter the size—feels like an opportunity to offer something homemade. This year, holiday baking gets a spirited upgrade thanks to our lineup of craft spirits, which lend depth, warmth, and just the right touch of festivity to classic seasonal treats.

This season, we’re blurring the lines between the bar cart and the bakery. From nostalgic gingerbread to peppermint-kissed pies, from rum-rich cookies to elegant cakes soaked in spiced or almond-infused spirits, these recipes bring big holiday flavor with approachable ease. From the warmth of our Spiced Rum to the sharp bite of Ginger Liqueur, these recipes don’t just use alcohol as a gimmick; they use it as a foundational flavor note that transforms "good" into "gourmet." Whether you're hosting a fireside cocktail party, contributing to a cookie exchange, or planning the grand finale to Christmas dinner, these New Deal–inspired baked goods will quickly become annual traditions.

Spiced Rum and Almond Pound Cake
Spiced Rum and Almond Pound Cake

Spiced Rum and Almond Pound Cake

A Holiday Loaf with Luxurious Depth

This pound cake is pure elegance: dense, buttery, gently sweet, and fragrant with almond extract and Spiced Rum. Whether baked in a bundt or loaf pan, the dense, golden crumb is tight and velvety, yellow-hued from the eggs and butter. It’s soaked in Spiced Rum syrup while still warm, ensuring every bite is moist and fragrant. The rum adds warmth and complexity without overpowering the delicate crumb, and the flavor is a classic marriage of almond and rum—nutty, buttery, and warming, with a glaze that adds a final sugary crackle. Plus, it looks stunning on a cake stand and will keep up to four day sat room temperature.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Perfect for slicing and serving beside warm beverages at an afternoon holiday tea party, sliced for a holiday brunch, or the sophisticated finish to a New Year's Eve dinner party.
Pair roasted pork with cranberry glaze, wild rice pilaf with dried cranberries and toasted almonds, and a winter citrus salad. Or, serve at brunch with fresh fruit, a cheese plate, and coffee.

A glass of Amontillado sherry, a lightly oaked chardonnay, or a brut rosé is a recommended wine pairing.
Ginger Molasses Cookies
Ginger Molasses Cookies

Ginger Molasses Cookies

Soft, Spiced & Buttery

Imagine a cookie that feels like a warm hug. Soft and chewy with crisp edges, these ginger molasses cookies get an aromatic boost from our New Deal Ginger Liqueur, giving the cookies a lingering, cozy heat. These are substantial, crinkled beauties with a deep mahogany color, drizzled with a pale, sweet glaze. Flavor-wise, they are an explosion of spice—molasses, cinnamon, and a double-dose of ginger from both the ground spice and the New Deal Ginger Liqueur in the dough and glaze. The liqueur adds a fresh, zesty heat that cuts through the rich molasses. The texture is spot-on: tender but sturdy enough to dip into milk, cider, or hot toddies.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


These are your go-to for a cozy Hygge night in, as the star of a holiday care package, and on holiday cookie platters. They travel beautifully and taste even better a day later.
Serve with a hearty beef and barley Stew, roasted root vegetables with a maple glaze, or baked brie with cranberry chutney and winter squash soup.

A batch of Mulled Wine, fortified with Ginger Liqueur and Distiller's Workshop Brandy, or a jammy Zinfandel.
Eggnog Poke Cake
Eggnog Poke Cake

Eggnog Poke Cake

Holiday Comfort in Every Bite

If the holidays had an official flavor, it might be eggnog—and this Eggnog Poke Cake captures it in its coziest form. Inspired by the iconic Mexican Tres Leches cake, this light sponge cake becomes incredibly decadent after being poked and soaked with a mixture of eggnog and brandy. The texture is incredibly moist—almost pudding-like—and the flavor is pure holiday nostalgia: creamy custard, vanilla, and the warming heat of good brandy. topped with a layer of whipped cream and dusted with nutmeg, this sponge cake is ridiculously easy to make and comes together fast, making this a no-brainer dessert the busy and hectic holiday season.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Perfect for an office holiday potluck or Friendsmas gathering. It’s easy to transport right in its baking dish and is always a crowd-pleaser.
Serve with spiral-cut ham with honey mustard glaze, potato gratin, and dinner rolls with herbed butter.

For cocktail pairing, try a Spiced Rum Old Fashioned, Egg Nog, or a Hot "Buttered" Rum.
For wine drinkers, try a cream sherry served neat with an orange slice, or something sparkling like brut champagne or prosecco.
Spiced Rum Meltaway Cookies
Spiced Rum Meltaway Cookies

Spiced Rum Meltaway Cookies

Buttery Holiday Snowflakes

These aren't your average sugar cookies. These delicate meltaways live up to their name—one bite, and they dissolve on your tongue like the first snowfall of December. New Deal Spiced Rum weaves cinnamon, nutmeg, and vanilla notes throughout the dough, making each cookie taste like the essence of holiday baking. The buttery shortbread base is lifted by the zest of fresh orange and the warm, vanilla-cinnamon notes of the Spiced Rum. It’s a sophisticated, aromatic bite that feels lighter than air. Dusted generously with powdered sugar, they look as though they were dipped in fresh snow, making them visually perfect for winter dessert boards or festive tins.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


These bite-sized treasures are perfect for grazing while mingling. Serve at an afternoon Holiday Tea, a tree-trimming party, or at a rum-focused cocktail tasting night.
Pairs well with a savory Quiche Lorraine or spinach & gruyère galette, a crisp fennel & citrus salad, or with sharp cheeses like aged Gouda or Manchego.

For cocktail pairing, try a homemade Egg Nog, a Harvest Moon, or a Vanilla Apple Sour.
A chilled Moscato d'Asti or Asti Spumante is a recommended wine pairing. The bubbles cut the butter, while the sweetness complements the powdered sugar.
Boozy Caramel Sauce
Boozy Caramel Sauce

Boozy Caramel Sauce

A holiday essential

If holiday desserts had a universal language, caramel would be it. This Boozy Caramel Sauce, made with one of New Deal’s boldly flavored craft spirits (try Spiced RumDistiller's Workshop Brandy, Coffee, or Ginger Liqueur), is a silky, glossy caramel that pours like warm satin. This isn't a baked good itself, but the ultimate accessory for them. Deep amber in color and intensely aromatic, it tastes of toasted sugar and warm butter, rounded out by the complexity of whichever spirit you choose. Spiced Rum adds vanilla notes; Ginger Liqueur adds heat; Coffee Liqueur adds earthiness. Makes a great gift for your favorite sweet tooth!

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Drizzle over Christmas Eve desserts, serve at a DIY Sundae Bar on New Year's Day, or as a topping for a Leftover Pie Party.
Drizzle hot over vanilla bean ice cream, a slice of apple or pear pie, or bread pudding. Or, serve with fresh fruit trays for a light-ish finish to a holiday meal.

The caramel and nut flavors in a Tawny Port or Madeira are natural companions to this sauce. For contrast, try a late-harvest Riesling.
Gingerbread Snack Cake
Gingerbread Snack Cake

Gingerbread Snack Cake

Simple, rustic, and perfectly spiced

This is the kind of cake grandmothers made when company dropped by unexpectedly—but elevated with New Deal Ginger Liqueur for a modern twist. Deeply spiced, moist, and airy, the Gingerbread Snack Cake carries notes of molasses, cinnamon, clove, and candied ginger. The browned butter base provides a nutty undertone, while the Ginger Liqueur and molasses create a deep, spicy heat that lingers. Whether you dust it with powdered sugar or top it with the tangy sour cream frosting studded with bits of candied ginger that glisten like jewels, the flavor profile is intensely warming and cozy. Its aroma alone will draw every person in the house toward the kitchen.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Sturdy enough to eat with your hands but elegant enough for a fork, it's perfect for Christmas Morning Brunch, or a Post-Sledding Warm-Up.
Serve with Shakshuka, crispy hash browns, and thick-cut bacon slices.

For wine drinkers, try an aromatic Gewürztraminer, Pedro Ximenez Sherry, or a dry cider.
Rum Balls
Rum Balls

Rum Balls

Rich, nostalgic, perfect for gifting

A retro classic reimagined! Rum Balls are a holiday classic for good reason—they’re easy, irresistibly rich, and require no baking. Soft, fudgy, and rolled in cocoa or powdered sugar, these little bites taste like a cross between truffles and cookies, with just enough boozy brightness to make them feel like a grown-up treat. The flavor is an unapologetic boozy punch of spiced rum, mellowed by vanilla and the nutty richness of the pecans. They are sweet, potent, and utterly addictive. New Deal Spiced Rum adds warmth, depth, and a molasses-kissed spice profile that sets your batch apart from every grandma’s-secret-recipe at the cookie swap.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Holiday finger food at its finest, serve these as the ultimate Cocktail Hour sweet, at a White Elephant gift exchange, or fill a decorative tin and gift as stocking stuffers.
Serve on dessert boards with truffles, nuts, and dried fruit, or on a charcuterie board featuring sharp cheddars and cured meats, or alongside goat cheese-stuffed bacon-wrapped dates.

For wine drinkers, pair with Amontillado Sherry—it's nutty oxidation mirrors the pecans and rum—or, a Ruby Port or Cabernet Sauvignon.
Peppermint Patty Pie
Peppermint Patty Pie

Peppermint Patty Pie

A Festive Showstopper

If ever a dessert captured the spirit of winter holidays in a single bite, it’s the Peppermint Patty Pie. Velvety, cool, and intensely chocolate-mint, this pie features a chocolate cookie crust filled with a creamy, mint-infused center lifted by Mud Puddle Bitter Chocolate Vodka and Spiritopia Peppermint Liqueur. It features a dark, silky chocolate custard set inside a crisp crust, topped with billowing clouds of peppermint-infused whipped cream. The taste is exactly like your favorite mint chocolate candy, but deconstructed and elevated. The Mud Puddle Vodka adds a bitter cocoa depth that prevents the pie from being too sweet, while the peppermint cream offers a cool, refreshing finish for the perfect finale to a heavy holiday meal.

Raise a Glass, Share a Plate, Make a Memory


Serve as the grand finale of a formal Christmas Dinner, at winter birthday celebrations, or at a holiday movie night.
Serve herb-crusted prime rib or mushroom Wellington, garlic mashed potatoes, creamed spinach, and roasted Brussels sprouts with balsamic glaze.

For wine drinkers, pair with a bold red with tannins, like a Cabernet Sauvignon, a red blend with chocolate notes, or a vintage Port.

Cheers to Baking Spirits Bright

This holiday season, let your baking rack do the talking. From spiced rum to ginger liqueur, vodka to peppermint liqueur, each adds dimension, aroma, and seasonal warmth to your baking, transforming classic treats into memorable holiday centerpieces. Whether you are looking for the spicy snap of a ginger cookie or the creamy indulgence of an eggnog cake, our craft spirits provide that "secret ingredient" your guests won't be able to stop guessing. Whether you're hosting a cozy gathering, preparing gifts, or simply indulging in a quiet baking afternoon as the rain taps at the window, these recipes promise to bring joy—and a little spirited cheer—to every celebration. So, preheat your ovens, uncork a bottle, and get ready to host the most spirited event of the year.

Back to blog